Warning: this is a book you either love or hate. Why this is, I don’t know. But, dear reader, consider yourself warned. I fell more on the “hate” side of this equation but, surprisingly, enjoyed the film.
My negative reaction to Paper Towns surprised me because I loved The Fault in Our Stars so much. I know that John Green can write amazing, sympathetic characters. He chose not to in this one and I’ve been rolling it around my brain- wondering why. Right off the bat, the reader is thrown into Margo and Quentin’s lives and we’re exposed to some of their worst traits rather than their best. Usually, people behave their best when you first get to know them and then, as they become comfortable with you, they let some of their more questionable sides out. The whole “rolling around the neighborhood at night and causing mayhem” part of Paper Towns isn’t fun because we don’t really know these characters yet. It’s easier to forgive adolescent hijinks when you know and love the people who are doing them, but we’ve got almost zero time to form a connection before they’re breaking laws.
I think I would have given up on Paper Towns if I hadn’t watched John Green’s TedTalks video on the topic. If you haven’t seen it yet, here it is:https://youtu.be/NgDGlcxYrhQ
The basic idea behind a paper town (a made up town on a map) was copyright protection but the coolest part is that the mapmakers took something that wasn’t real and made it real because they presented it that way for so long. So, anyway, I think that John wrote the characters in this story like a paper town. At first, he presents the main characters as over-the-top clichés of what teenagers could be. The reader isn’t necessarily meant to bond with them at this point, they’re not real, they’re just “people on paper”.
Then, through the second part of the book, let’s call it the “clue finding” part, John slowly reveals more and more of the real parts of their characters just as Quentin finds more and more clues to where Margo has gone. Their hopes and dreams, relationships, daily struggles, hopes, tedious moments… they’re becoming more real. Finally, in the last third, as we join the characters on their mad rush to find Margo, they’ve become real. Real enough to have some close life-threatening moments on the road. Though they started out fake, John built enough substance around and on top of the characters so that they have heft and dimension. So, that’s my theory on why he wrote such awful characters- he meant to. But, I still never managed to like any of them very much, even after they became “real”.
John starts out strong in his prologue: “The way I figure it, everyone gets a miracle. Like, I will probably never be struck by lightning, or win a Nobel Prize, or become the dictator of a small nation in the Pacific Islands, or contract terminal ear cancer, or spontaneously combust. … My miracle was this: out of all the houses in all the subdivisions in all of Florida, I ended up living next door to Margo Roth Spiegelman.” pg 15 (ebook)
“Margo always loved mysteries. And in everything that came afterward, I could never stop thinking that maybe she loved mysteries so much that she became one.pg 23 (ebook) And that was pretty much the high point in this book for me, right there. It was all downhill afterwards.
John’s reason for writing Paper Towns, I’m guessing… : “… she looks like Margo Roth Spiegelman, this girl I have known since I was two- this girl who was an idea that I loved. And it is only now, when she closes her notebook and places it inside a backpack next to her and then stands up and walks toward us, that I realize that the idea is not only wrong but dangerous. What a treacherous thing it is to believe that a person is more than a person.” pg 406 (ebook)
In conclusion, if you haven’t read any of John Green’s books, please don’t start with this one. I highly recommend A Fault in Our Stars. It will break your heart. This one will just put you to sleep or make you mad… unless you’re one of those who “ships” this book. In which case, disregard everything I’ve just said. 🙂
Thanks for reading!